CFTC Nominees Face Senate Questions on Prediction Markets
Matt Rowland expressed sympathy for states and tribes as Nathan Anonick declined to take a position.

Key Takeaways
- CFTC nominee Matt Rowland expressed sympathy for states and tribes challenging federal jurisdiction over sports event contracts.
- Nominee Nathan Anonick declined to say whether a trade on an NFL game result constitutes sports betting.
- Three petitions ask the U.S. Supreme Court to resolve a circuit split over prediction market jurisdiction.
- Sen. Ben Ray Luján indicated both nominees would likely be confirmed during the lame-duck session.
Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) nominees Matt Rowland and Nathan Anonick faced Senate questions on prediction markets at a Tuesday hearing, with Rowland expressing sympathy for states and tribes contesting federal jurisdiction over sports event contracts. Anonick declined to say whether a trade on the result of an NFL game amounts to sports betting.
The Senate Agriculture Committee did not vote on the nominations. The committee record remains open for two days before a vote, while Sen. Ben Ray Luján indicated both nominees would likely win confirmation during the lame-duck session.
States, tribes and sports contracts
Democratic nominee Rowland told Sen. Tina Smith, a Minnesota Democrat, that he understood the concerns raised by states and tribes. He also said he could not say much about active litigation.
“I am sympathetic to the points states and tribes have raised.” — Matt Rowland
Smith said prediction market operators continued to offer sports contracts to her constituents after Minnesota became the first state to ban prediction markets in May. The CFTC sued Minnesota to block the law.
Smith argued that the law was clear on sports betting jurisdiction. She cited the 2018 Murphy v. NCAA ruling, which returned the power to legalise sports betting to states, and the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA), under which tribes have authority.
Both nominees agreed that Murphy granted the powers Smith described and that CFTC rules prohibit gaming contracts. Neither said what distinguishes a sports wager from a sports event contract. Rowland said courts had ruled both ways; Republican nominee Anonick described a complex and highly charged legal question on which courts disagree.
The dispute is headed toward the U.S. Supreme Court. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals sided with Kalshi, while the Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits sided with states. Three petitions ask the justices to resolve the question.
Senators challenge Selig's approach
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, a Republican, has been the sole commissioner for nearly a year at an agency intended to have five bipartisan members. For most of that period, he has used his lone vote to support Kalshi, Polymarket and competitors asserting CFTC jurisdiction, including in 12 lawsuits against states.
Sen. Adam Schiff, a California Democrat, described regulation of sports event contracts as the “Wild West”. He said Selig had presented himself as a blank slate during his own confirmation and pledged to look to the courts on prediction markets, but now openly tells operators to defy court orders.
“I don’t know that I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before.” — Sen. Adam Schiff
On Monday, Schiff led nine Democratic senators in a letter demanding that Selig reverse that direction and preserve communications dating from January 2025, when prediction markets began offering sports event contracts. The letter said the direction directly conflicts with active court orders in California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington. The senators gave Selig until Nov. 23 to respond.
Schiff pressed Anonick on the NFL example and asked whether he would defer to courts or tell them what to do. Anonick said he would rely on fact-finding with general counsel, outside counsel, tribes, states and other stakeholders. He said taking a preconceived position without that process would be irresponsible.
Enforcement and confirmation
Sen. Raphael Warnock, a Georgia Democrat, questioned reduced enforcement and staff cuts at the CFTC. He also raised concerns that the agency favours companies with ties to President Donald Trump. Rowland said the law must be enforced fairly, and Anonick said it must apply equally and fairly to everyone involved.
Trump nominated Rowland and Anonick last week, nine days after Democrats won control of Congress in the midterm elections. During the hearing, the nominees also faced questions about an agency that senators said had placed more focus on technology than on the farmers it was established to oversee.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happened to Minnesota's prediction market ban?
The CFTC sued Minnesota to block its law banning prediction markets. Sen. Tina Smith said operators were still offering sports contracts to her constituents after the state adopted the ban in May.
What did senators ask Michael Selig to do about court orders?
Sen. Adam Schiff and nine Democratic senators asked Selig to reverse his direction to operators and preserve communications dating from January 2025. Their letter cited active court orders in California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington and set a Nov. 23 deadline for his response.
What enforcement concerns did Raphael Warnock raise?
Warnock questioned enforcement reductions and staff cuts at the CFTC, as well as potential favouritism towards companies with ties to Donald Trump. Both nominees said the law must be applied fairly.
How did Nathan Anonick say he would assess sports event contracts?
Anonick said he would rely on fact-finding involving counsel, tribes, states and other stakeholders before taking a position. He told senators that reaching a preconceived view without that process would be irresponsible.
Tags
About the author

Tessa Coleman
Betting Markets Correspondent
Tessa Coleman covers betting products and markets — sportsbook launches, odds and trading technology, and the fast-growing prediction-market space from regulated exchanges to event contracts. The stories lead with the product or the ruling, name the operators and platforms precisely, and translate trading jargon into what bettors can actually do. When a book reworks its pricing or a prediction market wins a license fight, Tessa Coleman explains the mechanics and the stakes.
More from Tessa Coleman








