Nine Senators Challenge CFTC Prediction Market Geofencing Order
The lawmakers also seek preservation of agency records dating back to January 2025.

Key Takeaways
- Nine Democratic senators want the CFTC to reverse or suspend its November 5 directive on prediction market geographic restrictions.
- The senators asked the CFTC to preserve prediction market communications dating back to January 1, 2025, and confirm compliance by November 23.
- Federal courts have restricted certain prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada, Washington and two California tribal jurisdictions.
- The CFTC and prediction exchanges assert federal authority over the contracts, while state and tribal authorities maintain that gambling laws remain enforceable.
Nine Democratic US senators have called on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to withdraw its November 5 directive requiring prediction exchanges to remove domestic geographic restrictions within 30 days. They say the order conflicts with court rulings and state gambling laws, and have separately demanded that the agency preserve prediction market communications.
Senators seek records and a pause on enforcement
The lawmakers want the CFTC to withdraw the directive or suspend enforcement until courts resolve pending cases. They also requested confirmation that exchanges can retain geographic restrictions to comply with court orders, tribal gaming agreements or voluntary access policies.
Their preservation request covers communications dating back to January 1, 2025. That month, Kalshi introduced sports event contracts ahead of the Super Bowl. The senators asked the agency to retain official and personal emails, text messages, encrypted messaging app communications, calendars and meeting notes. They also want automatic deletion functions disabled and compliance confirmed by November 23.
Braden Perry, a former CFTC senior trial attorney and now co-founding partner at Kennyhertz Perry LLC, said the request could signal a broader congressional investigation.
“A letter from senators is not a subpoena, and it has no legal force on its own. But it puts the agency on notice. If records go missing later, no one at the CFTC can say they did not know to keep them. This language reads like a first step toward something bigger,” Perry said.
The request comes ahead of Democrats taking control of both chambers of Congress in January 2027. Stephen Piepgrass of Troutman Pepper Locke said lawmakers have identified investigations into potential executive overreach as a priority.
Court orders and the CFTC directive
The dispute concerns the CFTC's interpretation of its impartial access rule. On November 5, the commission instructed designated contract markets to remove domestic geographic restrictions within 30 days or explain why they could not comply.
Federal courts have restricted certain prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as on lands belonging to Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians. The CFTC issued its interpretation hours after US District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley restricted Kalshi sports contracts on the two California tribal lands.
In a letter to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, the senators challenged both the timing and the substance of the decision.
“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” the senators wrote.
California Senator Adam Schiff led the group. The other signatories were Alex Padilla, Elissa Slotkin, Gary Peters, Catherine Cortez Masto, Jacky Rosen, Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray and Amy Klobuchar.
Federal authority remains in dispute
Selig maintains that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC authority over federally registered prediction exchanges, even where states classify their sports contracts as gambling. When announcing the directive, he argued for a national approach.
“Derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale in order to achieve the purposes set out in the Commodity Exchange Act,” Selig said.
The commission has challenged state enforcement actions in cases involving Michigan and New York and has filed lawsuits against Arkansas and Louisiana. Louisiana became the 12th state involved in litigation over CFTC authority.
The disagreement centres on federal preemption: prediction exchanges say federal derivatives regulation overrides conflicting state restrictions, while state and tribal authorities maintain that gambling laws remain enforceable.
Selig remains the CFTC's sole commissioner, although the agency has five authorised seats. Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland faced a Senate Agriculture Committee confirmation hearing on November 17.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the CFTC tell prediction exchanges to do?
The CFTC instructed designated contract markets to remove domestic geographic restrictions within 30 days or explain why they could not comply. It issued the interpretation of its impartial access rule on November 5.
Which senators signed the letter to the CFTC?
California Senator Adam Schiff led a group of nine Democratic senators. The other signatories were Alex Padilla, Elissa Slotkin, Gary Peters, Catherine Cortez Masto, Jacky Rosen, Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray and Amy Klobuchar.
Why did the timing of the CFTC order draw criticism?
The interpretation came hours after US District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley restricted Kalshi sports contracts on two California tribal lands. Those lands belong to Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians.
How many commissioners currently serve at the CFTC?
Michael Selig is the CFTC's sole commissioner, although the agency has five authorised seats. Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland faced a Senate Agriculture Committee confirmation hearing on November 17.
Tags
About the author

Tessa Coleman
Betting Markets Correspondent
Tessa Coleman covers betting products and markets — sportsbook launches, odds and trading technology, and the fast-growing prediction-market space from regulated exchanges to event contracts. The stories lead with the product or the ruling, name the operators and platforms precisely, and translate trading jargon into what bettors can actually do. When a book reworks its pricing or a prediction market wins a license fight, Tessa Coleman explains the mechanics and the stakes.
More from Tessa Coleman








