iGAMINGHOUSE
Prediction Market

Schiff Accuses CFTC Chair Selig of Misleading Senate

Commission nominees faced questions on sports contracts, tribal authority and staffing.

By Tessa ColemanPublished Nov 18, 20265 min readUSA
Senate hearing on CFTC nominees and oversight of sports prediction market contracts

Key Takeaways

  • Senator Adam Schiff accused CFTC Chairman Michael Selig of misleading lawmakers about his approach to sports event contracts.
  • CFTC nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland declined to take definitive positions on the legality of sports event contracts.
  • Senator Michael Bennet said listed contracts rose 167% from 2024 to 2026 while the CFTC lost about 25% of its staff.
  • Confirmation of both nominees would bring the CFTC to three members and leave two of its five authorized seats vacant.

Senator Adam Schiff accused Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chairman Michael Selig of misleading lawmakers about his approach to sports prediction markets at a November 17, 2026 confirmation hearing. The Senate Agriculture Committee was questioning two prospective commissioners, Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland, about the agency’s oversight of event contracts.

Schiff, a California Democrat, said Selig had promised a “blank slate” during his own 2025 confirmation hearing and had pledged to defer to the courts. Since taking office, Selig has defended federal jurisdiction over prediction markets and challenged geographic restrictions imposed by states.

Schiff challenges Selig’s record

Schiff read from Selig’s earlier testimony, including assurances that he would not prejudge whether sports event contracts were gambling. He questioned whether Selig had lied to senators or changed his mind after confirmation.

“I don’t know that I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before,” Schiff said. “This is certainly not the kind of leadership that we need at CFTC.”

Schiff accused the chairman of filing briefs to tell courts what to do and, when rulings went against prediction markets, effectively telling companies to disregard court orders, geofencing and state and tribal laws.

The senator asked Anonick whether a contract on the outcome of Thursday’s Colts-Texans NFL game was a sports bet. Anonick said the legal question was complex because federal courts had reached conflicting decisions. He declined to prejudge a future vote or say he would follow Selig’s lead.

Anonick said he would make his own decisions after thorough fact-finding and consultation with the CFTC’s Office of General Counsel, outside counsel, tribes, states and other stakeholders. Schiff urged him to keep that commitment and said he hoped he would not need to revisit the testimony at a later hearing.

State and tribal authority

Senator Tina Smith, a Minnesota Democrat, questioned whether there was any practical difference between a sports wager and an event contract on the same outcome. She cited CFTC lawsuits against states seeking to restrict sports prediction markets and argued that federal law protects state and tribal authority over gaming.

Rowland acknowledged the conflicting court decisions and declined to take a position on the ongoing litigation. He said he understood Smith’s practical argument, was sympathetic to state and tribal concerns and wanted to work with them if confirmed.

Anonick also cited legal uncertainty and said he had heard concerns from tribal representatives that he would consider before making regulatory decisions. Smith challenged his description of the dispute as emotionally charged, saying it involved established rights under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act and state authority over sports gaming.

Ranking Member Amy Klobuchar, also a Minnesota Democrat, asked Rowland about the CFTC’s duty to assess whether contracts involving gaming and other restricted activities are contrary to the public interest. Rowland said ongoing rulemaking should balance the public interest against the contracts’ economic usefulness. He anticipated a possible Supreme Court ruling within the next two terms and said the agency would be bound by it.

Retail protections and staffing

Klobuchar asked how the CFTC should respond as more retail customers participate in prediction markets and digital-asset derivatives, including when platforms offer new products to less experienced traders. Rowland said the agency should consider stronger customer protections, rules on conflicts of interest at vertically integrated platforms, and marketing and advertising requirements. In his opening testimony, he called for customer protection rules to be re-examined and strengthened as retail participation grows.

Senator Michael Bennet, a Colorado Democrat, questioned whether the agency had enough resources to monitor markets for fraud, manipulation and insider trading. He said the number of contracts listed for trading rose 167% between 2024 and 2026, while the CFTC lost about 25% of its staff over the same period.

Rowland, a longtime CFTC attorney and National Treasury Employees Union member, referred to significant staff attrition and disruption in 2025. He said he wanted to work with Selig and fellow commissioners to restore appropriate staffing and return enforcement to its historical size and activity level.

Anonick said he would first seek detailed briefings on staffing, hiring plans and gaps in technical expertise before deciding where further resources were needed.

Commission vacancies and next steps

Senator Raphael Warnock, a Georgia Democrat, pressed the nominees on restoring a full, bipartisan five-member commission instead of continuing with Selig as its sole member. Both supported filling the remaining vacancies. Rowland said he hoped their service, if confirmed, would demonstrate the benefits of a bipartisan commission.

Bennet asked whether they would support longer public comment periods for significant rulemakings, particularly those started while Selig was the only commissioner. Both backed adequate opportunities for stakeholder participation.

Warnock separately raised allegations that political appointees had interfered in CFTC investigations involving companies connected to President Donald Trump’s family. He asked whether those ties should affect the agency’s treatment of regulated firms.

“I think that the law needs to be enforced fairly, without fear or favor, and so the answer is no,” Rowland said.

Anonick agreed that political connections should not affect enforcement and said he would examine interference allegations if confirmed.

The nominees were sworn in before the committee on November 17. The next step is a committee vote on advancing them to the full Senate. Committee Chairman John Boozman, an Arkansas Republican, said he hoped the nominations could move quickly.

Confirmation would bring the commission to three members, restore bipartisan representation and leave two of its five authorized seats vacant.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Schiff say Selig had promised about sports contracts?

Schiff said Selig promised to approach their legality with a blank slate and defer to the courts. He cited Selig’s 2025 confirmation testimony and accused him of subsequently challenging state restrictions and opposing court rulings unfavourable to prediction markets.

How did the nominees address tribal gaming rights?

Both nominees said they would consider tribal concerns. Matthew Rowland expressed sympathy for states and tribes, while Nathan Anonick said he had heard from tribal representatives. Senator Tina Smith cited rights under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.

What customer protections did Rowland raise?

Rowland said the CFTC should consider stronger protections for retail customers and rules addressing platform conflicts of interest. He also identified marketing and advertising requirements as areas for consideration as less experienced traders encounter new products.

What happens next to the CFTC nominations?

The Senate Agriculture Committee must vote on whether to advance the nominations to the full Senate. Committee Chairman John Boozman said he hoped they could move quickly.

Tags

CFTCprediction-marketssports-event-contractstribal-gamingus-regulation

About the author

Tessa Coleman

Tessa Coleman

Betting Markets Correspondent

Tessa Coleman covers betting products and markets — sportsbook launches, odds and trading technology, and the fast-growing prediction-market space from regulated exchanges to event contracts. The stories lead with the product or the ruling, name the operators and platforms precisely, and translate trading jargon into what bettors can actually do. When a book reworks its pricing or a prediction market wins a license fight, Tessa Coleman explains the mechanics and the stakes.

More from Tessa Coleman

Related Articles

Gamble Responsibly

NCPGMalta Gaming AuthorityGambleAwareGLIGamCareeCOGRA18+

iGamingHouse is intended for users who are 18 years or older (or the legal age in your jurisdiction). Ensure online gambling is legal in your region before participating. Seek help from professional resources if you feel you have a gambling problem. Terms and conditions apply. All rights reserved © 2026.