Prosecutors challenge missing-witness instruction in Clase trial
The Brooklyn court is weighing how jurors should treat the absence of bettor Enoc Pena.

Key Takeaways
- Prosecutors asked the Brooklyn court on 19 November 2026 to remove a proposed missing-witness instruction concerning Enoc Pena.
- The government confirmed it would not call Pena and asked that jurors be told to draw no inference against either side.
- The draft verdict sheet places all three defendants on the wire fraud conspiracy count, but only Emmanuel Clase de la Cruz and Luis Leandro Ortiz Ribera on the other three counts.
- The indictment alleges that two unnamed sportsbooks were defrauded through wagers barred by their terms of use.
Federal prosecutors asked a Brooklyn court on 19 November 2026 to remove a proposed missing-witness instruction from the jury charge in the trial of Emmanuel Clase de la Cruz, Luis Leandro Ortiz Ribera and Robinson Vasquez Germosen. They confirmed they would not call cooperating bettor Enoc Pena and want jurors told not to draw an inference against either side from his absence.
What the prosecution wants the jury told
The request came in a government letter filed on 19 November, after the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York docketed a draft verdict sheet on 18 November. Prosecutors said the same filing contained the proposed jury charge, including the missing-witness instruction at pages 21 to 22. The charge itself is not publicly available on the docket.
The government said it presumed the instruction addressed the possibility that Pena, identified as Bettor-1 in earlier defence filings, would not testify. Prosecutors argued that Clase and Ortiz had each moved before trial to prevent Pena from taking the stand and should not now receive a missing-witness charge.
“The government's decision not to call Pena effectively grants the defendants the relief that they sought.” — Government letter, 19 November
Prosecutors asked Judge Kiyo A. Matsumoto to resolve the issue before the charging conference and before the government rests its case. Their preferred instruction would tell jurors not to draw an inference against either party. The letter said the Second Circuit described that approach as preferred in United States v. Johnson (2024).
The government also disputed the relevance of United States v. Torres (1988), the Second Circuit case cited for the proposed charge. Quoting Torres, prosecutors said courts have been reluctant to find a witness unavailable where the defence has “no real interest in calling the witness to the stand”. They argued that the defence was not seeking Pena's evidence because his witness material was “replete with inculpatory information” against the defendants.
Pena's availability and earlier account
Pena's lawyer, Michael Weil, has repeatedly said his client would testify if called, according to the government. Prosecutors said Weil told both sides as recently as 17 November that Pena was “prepared to testify for either side in the trial if called as a witness”. Neither side has called him.
The government said Clase's lawyers had met Pena for several hours in total. After an interview in August 2025, Pena signed a sworn declaration. A Clase filing described that declaration as having “completely denied any communications or discussions with Mr. Clase regarding gambling on baseball”.
The government offered a different account of the material in its possession, saying Pena's witness material implicated the defendants. Prosecutors said they had produced 62 items of Section 3500 witness material concerning Pena, most of them on 21 August 2026. The disputed instruction concerns what jurors may be told about his absence from the witness box.
What the draft verdict sheet covers
The draft verdict sheet, marked Court Exhibit 1A, lists four counts. All three defendants appear on Count One, wire fraud conspiracy. Only Clase and Ortiz appear on the other three counts: honest services wire fraud conspiracy, conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery, and money laundering conspiracy.
The indictment, dated 5 November 2025, frames Count One as a scheme to defraud two unnamed sportsbooks. Their terms of use barred wagers based on non-public information from an athlete. Count Two names the Cleveland Guardians and MLB as the parties allegedly deprived of honest services.
Vasquez Germosen appears only on the first count in the draft sheet. The jury questions on the remaining counts concern Clase and Ortiz alone.
Trial and docket record
The docket shows that the trial before Matsumoto sat on 12, 13, 16, 17, 18 and 19 November. Minute entries for the first four days record witnesses being sworn and exhibits being entered. The court record uses the defendants' full names: Emmanuel Clase de la Cruz, Luis Leandro Ortiz Ribera and Robinson Vasquez Germosen.
The 18 November order attaching the draft sheet is ECF 346; the sheet itself is ECF 346-1. The prosecution's 19 November request is ECF 347. Docket 1:25-cr-00346 records entries from 11 to 19 November, including the trial entries and the two filings.
In August, the players' union told Congress that MLB would not join it in lobbying against in-game props and event contracts. The prosecution's request leaves the proposed treatment of Pena's absence for the court to decide before the government rests.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do prosecutors say the missing-witness instruction is unwarranted?
Prosecutors say Clase and Ortiz had sought to prevent Pena from testifying before trial. Their letter argues that not calling him gives the defendants the relief they had requested.
Was Enoc Pena available to testify in the Clase trial?
Pena's lawyer said he was prepared to testify for either side if called. Prosecutors said Michael Weil communicated that position as recently as 17 November 2026.
What did Pena say about gambling discussions with Clase?
Pena signed an August 2025 declaration that a Clase filing described as denying any communications or discussions with Clase about gambling on baseball. The government says his witness material inculpates the defendants.
What evidence material did prosecutors produce concerning Pena?
Prosecutors said they produced 62 items of Section 3500 witness material concerning Pena. Most were produced on 21 August 2026.
Tags
About the author

Tessa Coleman
Betting Markets Correspondent
Tessa Coleman covers betting products and markets — sportsbook launches, odds and trading technology, and the fast-growing prediction-market space from regulated exchanges to event contracts. The stories lead with the product or the ruling, name the operators and platforms precisely, and translate trading jargon into what bettors can actually do. When a book reworks its pricing or a prediction market wins a license fight, Tessa Coleman explains the mechanics and the stakes.
More from Tessa Coleman








