Business Owners Detail Kalshi Hedges in CFTC Swap Rule Comments
The submissions cover sports promotions, weather exposure and a conference travel risk.

Key Takeaways
- Business owners supported a CFTC proposal to explicitly include event contracts in the federal definition of swaps.
- One4One owner Justin Robinson put $1,500 into a Kalshi contract that would pay $10,000 if the New York Knicks swept the NBA Finals.
- Playably bought Kalshi contracts covering up to $25,000 in potential refunds from a Forme World Cup promotion.
- NEXTPredict spent approximately $12,000 on a contract that could have paid $3 million if at least half of inbound JFK Airport flights were canceled on October 21.
- Kalshi also supported a companion CFTC rule excluding casino-style gambling products from the definition of swaps.
Business owners told the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) that they used Kalshi event contracts to hedge commercial risks as the regulator considered a proposal to explicitly include the contracts in the federal definition of swaps. Public comments closed on November 18, 2026, with submissions describing exposures tied to sports, weather and travel.
Promotional and event companies, bars and other merchants supported the proposal. The rule would reinforce federal oversight of contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather while states pursue legal challenges seeking to regulate sports event contracts as gambling.
What the sports hedges covered
Justin Robinson, owner of New York bar One4One, told the CFTC that he put $1,500 into a Kalshi contract that would pay $10,000 if the New York Knicks swept the NBA Finals. Without a sweep, he said, at least one more game would be played and could bring the bar about $30,000 in sales.
Peter Bayne, owner of TallBoy in Washington, DC, described hedging a World Cup promotion that offered customers free tabs if Team USA won by a specified number of goals. He said the Kalshi position covered the business either way.
Playably CEO Angelo Ferro described a separate World Cup campaign for apparel brand Forme, which offered 100% cashback if Team USA reached the final. Playably bought Kalshi contracts to cover up to $25,000 in potential refunds.
Ferro said his company places limit orders rather than accepting the offered price, holds positions for the duration of a campaign and uses market prices to decide which promotions to offer and how to price them. He characterised the positions as management of a business liability, not speculation.
Kalshi has promoted commercial uses of event contracts for months through social media and a small-business hedging website. Several businesses featured in those promotions later filed CFTC comments. They included 28 Wishes, a Los Angeles ice cream shop that Kalshi profiled in August, before the rules were proposed.
How the legal test applies
The sports examples sit within a dispute over whether sports event contracts qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), the federal law governing derivatives markets. The CEA includes certain contracts tied to events with a “potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence” in its definition of swaps. Federal appeals courts have split on whether sports outcomes meet that standard.
In the Fourth Circuit's decision against Kalshi during the week of November 19, Judge Stephanie Thacker concluded in a concurring opinion that sports contracts were not swaps. Dissenting Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin took the opposite view, citing financial risks for businesses near stadiums alongside ticket sales, broadcasting revenue and sponsorships.
Benjamin distinguished individual game and season contracts from parlays and player props, which she said could not reasonably be used to hedge. The CFTC proposal and the state challenges leave the scope of federal regulation contested.
Weather and conference travel risks
Brothers Jason and James Jiang, who run 28 Wishes, submitted separate letters on using Kalshi weather contracts to offset lost revenue. James said sales fall roughly 30% to 40% when it rains or the temperature drops to around 70 degrees, calling that a direct economic consequence for the shop.
Jason said he had traded weather contracts for more than a year, initially spending around $20 to $30 a day. He said the positions helped offset earlier trades and some revenue lost to cold or rainy weather.
Pierre Lindh, co-founder and managing director of NEXTPredict, described a travel hedge for the company's October prediction markets conference in New York City. NEXTPredict owns NEXTPredict.io.
As NEXTPredict.io previously reported, the company spent approximately $12,000 on a position that could have paid $3 million if at least half of inbound flights at JFK Airport were canceled on October 21, the primary attendee travel day before the conference. Lindh said the cancellation trigger covered the risk of delegates being unable to attend, whether the cause was bad weather or geopolitical instability. He described the contract as a tool for protecting the company's ability to operate when outside events go wrong.
Letter templates and Kalshi's submission
Kalshi encouraged customers to comment through a dedicated advocacy website. Its questionnaire generated a draft letter from a customer's answers, which the customer could edit before submission.
Several business-owner letters reviewed by NEXTPredict.io used similar language, particularly in distinguishing exchange-traded contracts from traditional sportsbooks and arguing for consistent federal regulation. Bayne and James Jiang used identical wording to say they would not use a sportsbook to manage a real financial risk. James added that he preferred a supervised US exchange to an offshore alternative.
Other letters repeatedly noted that traders determine prices, positions can be sold before settlement and customer funds are held separately. The submissions also echoed a CEA provision referring to instruments “commonly known to the trade as a swap”; Robinson applied that wording to his own experience using a contract.
In its own November 18 submission, Kalshi argued that sports, political, cultural and weather events can have economic consequences without regulators proving a specific commercial use for every contract. The exchange said Congress's use of the word “potential” meant the CFTC did not need to empirically verify the economic consequences of each event.
Kalshi cited Rizzo's, a bar and restaurant near Chicago's Wrigley Field, which used event contracts to protect against a short Chicago Cubs playoff run. It also cited Garden Bar in Austin, which hedged against fans leaving early if the Texas Longhorns fell far behind in a game.
The exchange argued that individual player statistics and in-game developments can also have financial consequences: a close game can draw more television viewers than a blowout, while player contracts can include bonuses tied to statistical results.
Kalshi also backed the CFTC's companion rule excluding casino-style gambling products from the definition of swaps. It argued that exchange-listed sports contracts differ from sportsbook offerings because they provide transparent orderbook execution, central clearing and access to exchange liquidity for selling a position.
States and gaming interests dispute the distinction. They argue that offering sports contracts on a federally regulated exchange does not necessarily make them financial derivatives.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are sports event contracts being disputed in federal courts?
Federal appeals courts have split over whether sports outcomes meet the Commodity Exchange Act's standard for swaps. In the Fourth Circuit decision against Kalshi, Judge Stephanie Thacker said sports contracts were not swaps, while dissenting Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin took the opposite view.
How did 28 Wishes use Kalshi weather contracts?
The Los Angeles ice cream shop used weather contracts to offset lost revenue. James Jiang said sales fall roughly 30% to 40% in rain or when temperatures drop to around 70 degrees; his brother Jason said he initially spent around $20 to $30 a day on contracts.
Did Kalshi help customers prepare comments for the CFTC?
Kalshi offered a questionnaire that generated editable draft comments through an advocacy website. NEXTPredict.io found similar language in several business-owner letters, including passages distinguishing exchange contracts from sportsbooks.
What sports businesses did Kalshi cite in its own CFTC submission?
Kalshi cited Rizzo's near Chicago's Wrigley Field and Garden Bar in Austin. Rizzo's hedged against a short Chicago Cubs playoff run, while Garden Bar hedged against fans leaving early if the Texas Longhorns fell far behind.
Tags
About the author

Tessa Coleman
Betting Markets Correspondent
Tessa Coleman covers betting products and markets — sportsbook launches, odds and trading technology, and the fast-growing prediction-market space from regulated exchanges to event contracts. The stories lead with the product or the ruling, name the operators and platforms precisely, and translate trading jargon into what bettors can actually do. When a book reworks its pricing or a prediction market wins a license fight, Tessa Coleman explains the mechanics and the stakes.
More from Tessa Coleman








